Responsible Abortion Practices
Updated on July 28, 2007
Note: This is not an article about pro-life or pro-choice agendas. This is a personal essay about my opinion on abortion and the delicate balance between the rights of women and the rights of unborn children. I must admit that I have never and would never have an elective abortion, even if I became pregnant through an act of rape or incest, unless my own life was endangered by the pregnancy. However, I do not expect that everyone else should choose never to have an elective abortion.
When Does Personhood Begin?
Technically, every cell in your body is alive, so the question isn't when does life begin, but when does personhood begin? To determine the beginning of personhood, we must first define what it means to be a person. What makes us different than a clump of cells? Essentially, we are aware. We may not comprehend the meaning of our own existence. We may not even recognize ourselves as individuals. At some level, though, we know that we exist. We are aware of stimuli. We know when something feels good and when something feels bad. The problem is that we don't exactly know how or when this level of awareness is achieved. Figuring this out is vital to determining the beginning of personhood.
Does Personhood Start at Birth?
Many pro-choice advocates say that "the fetus is a person when the it is born." True, a baby is indeed a person when it is born. But, I must say I dislike this argument because it suggests that the baby was not a person just five minutes before its birth. A fetus five minutes away from being born is just as much a person as a baby born five minutes ago.
Does Personhood Start at Viability?
Some definitions of personhood include the idea that the baby must be able to survive outside of the mother's body. However, it wasn't long ago that a child born four weeks early was likely to die. Now that pre-mature child has a very good chance of survival because our medical technology has advanced so much. We've even been able to save the lives of babies born twenty weeks early! I believe that by twenty weeks of pregnancy, the baby is indeed a person and deserves all the rights of any born human being, including the right to live, and anyone having an elective abortion after the twentieth week is committing a type of murder with the exception of abortions conducted because continuing the pregnancy would result in life threatening physical harm to the mother or because the baby would be born with a serious defect and would not be expected to live for more than a short time, and/or the baby would be in agony or in a persistent vegetative state with no hope of improvement. I would support legislation to uphold the rights of the fetus after the twentieth week of pregnancy.
Does Personhood Start with Brain Waves?
In a fetus, brainwaves can be detected in the eighth week after conception (the tenth week of pregnancy). Do brain waves equal consciousness? Not necessarily. Somebody who is brain dead may have brainwaves that regulate pulse, breathing, digestion, etc., in the same way that nerves in the arms and legs can stimulate reflexes in the limbs in paraplegics. However, a person who is brain dead does not have an awareness that can be detected via brainwaves using our current understanding of the brain. A fetus without brainwaves certainly meets the criteria for being brain dead, even if that brain is developing.
It is possible that a fetus that has not achieved brain waves indicative of thinking does not have an awareness. However, what makes us so sure that we know which brain waves indicates awareness. I'm a huge fan of science, but science is full of "oops, I guess we were wrong about that" discoveries. We may one day find that awareness occurs before the development of frontal lobe brain wave activity or that awareness is possible in parts of the brain other than the frontal cortex. Then the question becomes, when do brain waves indicate awareness?
I favor error on the side of caution. I would rather assume that awareness begins at the moment brain wave activity starts and be wrong than kill a person because I assumed it wasn't a person yet. I do not believe everyone should be forced to hold this same standard.
Does Personhood Starts When the Spirit Enters the Body?
I'm not God, I don't know when the spirit enters the body. Some religious dogmas teach that the spirit enters the body at birth while other teach that it enters at conception. Some religions teach that there is no soul at all. There is too much disagreement among religions to even attempt to consolidate these teachings into a single idea about when the soul and body join together. I believe that since religion varies from person to person, we should not try to incorporate religion into general policies about the state of personhood.
If your religion teaches that the spirit enters the body at conception and that it's wrong to abort a body with a spirit, then don't have an elective abortion, but you should try to force other people to share your religious beliefs.
The Morning After Pill
The Morning After pill stops a pregnancy before brainwaves even exist. Therefore, I see this method of abortion as causing the expelling of tissue rather than "killing" a person, and I have no problem with it. I'm in favor of having the pill available over the counter without a prescription.
The controversy is that the tissue may potentially develop into a person. Eggs and sperm could potentially turn into persons given the right conditions as well, but I don't think we should protect reproductive cells just because they have potential. Likewise, with cloning progress, any cell with DNA can potentially produce life, but trying to protect every DNA filled cell is unrealistic. As far as I'm concerned, a clump of cells is just a clump of cells, no matter what potential it has.
Making Responsible Choices with Information
If the mother elects to have an abortion, she needs to make the decision with the best information possible. We should not allow women (or anyone for that matter) to blindly undergo any procedure without being fully informed.
An abortion should first be preceded by an ultrasound exam to determine the age of the fetus (dating by using the last-menstrual-period method is unreliable). This is a quick procedure that can be done the same day of the procedure.
The mother should be given mandatory education about basic fetal development, alternatives to abortion (including contact information for adoption agencies), and resources available for safety and economic concerns (such as protection from abusive family members as well as assistance programs for childcare, medical care, income, food, education, job training, etc.). This information can be given to the mother the day of the procedure or earlier.
The mother should also talk to a counselor before the procedure on the day of the procedure or earlier.
The most annoying thing I have heard from some women seeking an abortion is, "I don't want to know what the thing looks like. I don't want to know if it's alive. I just don't want to be pregnant." If knowing the information makes you feel guilty, then you're probably doing something that violates your values. If you have all the information and you feel comfortable with your decision, then feel free to continue.
Minors Having Abortions
Should minors be forced to get their parent's permission to have an abortion? No!
Sure, as a parent I would want to know if my daughter decided to get an abortion. I hope that she would feel comfortable enough to talk to me about it first. (If she didn't, I would have to blame myself for not making her feel comfortable.)
Ultimately, it's the decision of the pregnant girl, not the pregnant girl's parents. She is the one who will have to carry the child, give birth to the child, and decide to raise or adopt out the child.
If the girl has abusive parents, this would certainly cause safety concerns for her. I personally know girls who grew up with abusive parents. For any of them, admitting that they got pregnant could be an invitation to a beating. For some of them, admitting that they were considering abortion could be a death sentence. No person (especially a child) should ever be forced to enter a dangerous situation.
I'm also not in favor of requiring a judges ruling. For one thing, by the time the pregnant girl gets to see the judge, it's quite possible that the "clump of cells" may have developed into a person. On top of that, there's the fact that a judge is not a medical doctor. A judge should not be making health or medical decisions.
Using Abortions to Fight Poverty and Child Abuse
True, some children who would have been aborted will be born into households that are abusive and/or poor. If those children had been aborted, they would have never been born, so they would have never suffered abuse or known the sadness of poverty. But using that logic, we should go ahead and euthanize all children who may potentially be victims of abuse or poverty. Likewise, we should euthanize anyone who may potentially be faced with extreme hardship from any condition.
The most famous of such modern mass euthanasia was ordered by Hitler in 1939. It also happened during the Crusades when children were killed, so they wouldn't be converted to Christianity. It happened in the Roman Empire when fathers had the power to reject a newborn infant and abandon it, leaving it to die of hypothermia or dehydration. Such practices also happened in early Judeo-Christian culture. The only difference between those horrible acts of baby killing and aborting a viable fetus is that we have the technology now to kill those babies without having to see them first, reducing our guilt.
If we really wanted to fight poverty and child abuse, we would do more to establish, run, and fund programs that help young mothers and babies. Every child needs fully covered healthcare regardless of whether their parents can afford health insurance. Working families need assistance with childcare. Parents need education and job training, so they can get better jobs. They also need free parenting classes and access to free counseling programs and support groups. It's our duty to help families help themselves.
A Woman's Right
"But the woman has the right to decide what to do with her body..."
The moment I learned that I was pregnant for the first time, I realized that everything I did to my body would affect the body of my unborn infant. Everything I ate or drank or breathed would enter the bloodstream of my child. Every reckless behavior I did endangered my baby. This is the price of pregnancy: you lose your ability to be free of responsibility.
True, she has the right to do whatever she wishes to her body, but does she have the right to do whatever she wishes to her unborn child?
I feel that a mother who chooses to take recreational drugs, use tobacco products, or drink excessive alcohol while pregnant is guilty of child endangerment, just as a mother who leaves filled heroine needles on the floor of her child's home or forces her child to breathe second-hand smoke is guilty. Likewise, I feel that it is homicide to abort a fetus after it has achieved personhood.
Attacking the Mother, Harming the Fetus
Should it be illegal to injure a mother, causing the fetus to die? Yes. If I'm pregnant and you cause my baby to die, I certainly want you held responsible.
Is it murder? After the baby achieves personhood, killing the baby is murder if it is intentional. Otherwise, the crime should be manslaughter or some other equivalent. Likewise, if the fetus is injured, the offender is guilty of abusing a child.
If the baby has not achieved personhood, and the mother intended to keep the baby, then a serious crime still has been committed. The offender has taken away the mother's dream of having this child and caused emotional stress. We must define a new law to fit this crime.
The Bottom Line
If you really don't want to get pregnant, you should use multiple forms of birth control AT THE SAME TIME. (I'm a big fan of condoms used with spermicidal foams or gels and even birth control pills as backup. If you are certain you never want to have children again, consider getting surgically sterilized.)
If there is the potential of unwanted fertilization, take the morning after pill.
If you truly want to have an abortion, get informed before deciding to do the procedure and learn about your alternatives.
Sources: http://www.leaderu.com/orgs/tul/psychtoday9809.html
...by Feed